A Hampshire farmer, Philip Tickner, has been found not guilty of manslaughter after the case against him collapsed due to expert testimony.
Tickner, 63, from Upper Lanham, near Old Alresford, was accused of causing the death of his employee, Phillip France, 57, who tragically died in June 2021 after falling through a skylight while carrying out roofing work at Upper Lanham Farm.
The prosecution claimed Tickner had been grossly negligent in ensuring the safety of the three workers he tasked with dismantling a barn roof. However, after almost two weeks of trial proceedings, an expert witness, Mr Provan, provided evidence that undermined the prosecution's argument, making it impossible to prove gross negligence manslaughter.
Prosecutor Mark Watson KC explained: "It was crucial for the Crown to demonstrate a breach of duty that met the criminal standard. After reviewing the expert’s concessions, we concluded it would not be realistic to continue the case."
As a result, the jury was instructed to return a not guilty verdict for the charge of manslaughter, and the trial was brought to an early end.
Mrs Justice Eady acknowledged the prosecution's difficulties, stating: "There is insufficient evidence to convict Mr Tickner. To establish gross negligence, the breach must be exceptionally serious, and this has not been demonstrated."
MORE NEWS|https://www.thescottishfarmer.co.uk/news/24655054.farmers-views-invited-health-support-challenges/
She also voiced concerns about the handling of the case, referencing the significant cost involved: "Given the impact on public funds, as well as the cost to Mr Tickner, I am concerned about what review processes will be undertaken regarding the prosecution's approach."
Although Tickner was cleared of manslaughter, he has admitted to two health and safety violations related to the incident and is expected to be sentenced for these offences on Friday, October 18.
Malcolm Galloway, representing Tickner, declined to comment following the collapse of the case.
Comments: Our rules
We want our comments to be a lively and valuable part of our community - a place where readers can debate and engage with the most important local issues. The ability to comment on our stories is a privilege, not a right, however, and that privilege may be withdrawn if it is abused or misused.
Please report any comments that break our rules.
Read the rules here